How you take money out—whether by selling investments, withdrawing funds, or donating—can have just as much impact on your taxes as how you invest. Most people treat these decisions as simple cash moves, and that’s where unnecessary taxes show up.
Avoid doing this:
- Sell whatever investment is easiest
- Withdraw from the first account they think of
- Donate cash without considering alternatives
Those choices are convenient—but often tax-inefficient.
What “money out” decisions actually affect
Small changes in which assets you use and when you use them can materially change the outcome.
Selling or withdrawing money can:
- Trigger capital gains
- Increase taxable income for the year
- Affect eligibility for deductions or credits
- Change future tax outcomes
That’s why these decisions deserve just as much attention as contributions.
A few concepts to know (keep it simple)
Capital gains timing
Selling appreciated investments in a taxable account can create capital gains.
Whether those gains are taxed — and at what rate — depends on how long you’ve held the investment and whether you have losses elsewhere in your portfolio.
This is where earlier steps like tax-loss harvesting can directly offset gains from selling.
Which account you withdraw from
Not all withdrawals are treated the same for tax purposes:
Taxable accounts
Selling investments here can trigger capital gains. The tax depends on the size of the gain and the holding period.
Traditional retirement accounts (401(k), Traditional IRA)
Withdrawals are generally taxed as ordinary income, regardless of investment performance.
Roth accounts
Qualified withdrawals are typically tax-free, but using them earlier can reduce future tax-free growth.
Even relatively small withdrawals from the “wrong” account can:
- push you into a higher tax bracket
- eliminate deductions or credits
- increase future required withdrawals
Age-based rules
If you’re above certain age thresholds, withdrawals come with specific rules—and penalties if missed.
In particular, pay attention to Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) if you are over 73. RMDs must be taken on schedule from traditional retirement accounts. Missing one can result in significant penalties.
These rules apply whether or not you plan to withdraw voluntarily.
Charitable strategies (if you plan to give)
If you’re donating this year, how you give matters.
Donating appreciated investments
Donating appreciated investments instead of cash can:
- avoid capital gains tax
- potentially allow a deduction for the full market value
- deliver the same benefit to the charity
This often works better than selling and donating cash.
Donor Advised Funds (DAFs)
A DAF allows you to:
- take a tax deduction now
- decide which charities receive the funds later
This can be useful in higher-income years or when you want to combine multiple years of giving.
Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs, 70½+)
QCDs allow certain charitable donations to be made directly from IRAs.
They can also count toward RMDs and reduce taxable income.
What to do today in Mezzi
If you only do one thing today, do this first: Personalize your Mezzi AI so the information and scenarios you see are accurate. Then, ask Mezzi:
- “Would selling investments create capital gains for me?”
- “Which accounts would withdrawals likely come from?”
- “Would donating investments instead of cash change the tax outcome?”
- “Does a Donor Advised Fund make sense for my situation?”
- “Do any age-based withdrawal rules apply to me?”
Mezzi uses your actual accounts to help you explore these tradeoffs, instead of guessing.
Be wealthy,
Manish
Co-founder and CEO of Mezzi
Table of Contents
Book Free Consultation
Walk through Mezzi with our team, review your current situation, and ask any questions you may have.